The Ultimate HVAC Comparison Guide

Central Split vs. Packaged vs. Chilled Water vs. VRF

Selecting the right cooling system is the most critical MEP decision for any project. Whether you are developing a luxury residence in Maitama or a multi-story corporate headquarters in Lagos, the wrong choice can lead to astronomical energy bills and poor occupant comfort.

Quick Comparison: Features & Criteria

Feature Central Split Packaged Unit Chilled Water VRF
Best Fit Residential/Small Offices Retail/Schools High-rise/Hospitals Hotels/Mixed-use
Medium Refrigerant Refrigerant Chilled Water Refrigerant
Zoning Moderate Limited High Very High
Typical Lifespan 15–20 yrs 10–15 yrs 20–30 yrs 15–25 yrs
Operating Cost Moderate Moderate Low (at scale) Low-Moderate

🔎 Deep Dive by System Type

1. Central Split Systems Initial Cost: Moderate

Commonly found in Nigerian luxury homes, these systems use separate outdoor condensers and indoor air handlers connected by ductwork.

Strengths: Widely understood by local technicians and easier to repair than complex VRF systems.

Limitation: Ductwork requires significant ceiling space and must be perfectly sealed to prevent energy loss in our humid climate.

2. Packaged Units Initial Cost: Lower

An "all-in-one" solution where all components sit in a single outdoor unit (usually rooftop).

Best For: Standalone retail, schools, and modular buildings where indoor mechanical space is unavailable.

3. Chilled Water Systems Initial Cost: Highest

The gold standard for large-scale infrastructure. A central chiller cools water, which is then pumped throughout the building to Fan Coil Units (FCU).

The Jeffen Reds Edge: We recommend Chilled Water for hospitals and airports because of its 30-year lifespan and seamless integration with Building Management Systems (BMS).

4. VRF (Variable Refrigerant Flow) Initial Cost: Moderate-High

VRF systems modulate refrigerant flow to match the exact cooling load of each individual room.

Pros: Superior zoning—a hotel guest can have their room at 18°C while the office next door is at 23°C. It is incredibly efficient but requires highly specialized maintenance.

Which should you choose?

At Jeffen Reds Ltd, we analyze your project based on 5 key questions:

  1. How many separate zones require independent control?
  2. Is ductwork feasible given your ceiling heights?
  3. What is the design load variation? (Does the building empty out at night?)
  4. Maintenance: Do you have access to specialized VRF technicians, or do you need a simpler split system?
  5. Budget: Do you favor lower up-front costs or 25-year operational savings?

Expert HVAC Design & Commissioning

Don't leave your comfort to chance. From high-rise chillers to modular VRF systems, we design for the Nigerian environment.

Consult Our Engineers